Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Takes sacks at an alarming rate, getting brought down on 9.4% of dropbacks in 2024
• Needs to add significant strength and bulk to withstand the physical demands at the next level
• Sometimes holds onto the ball too long, preferring pocket passing over scrambling when protection breaks down
• Injury concerns after missing time in multiple games due to the beating he absorbed behind Cal's line
• Limited experience against elite competition may require adjustment period at the next level

Scouting Report: Summary

Watching Mendoza operate reveals a quarterback who thrives when the game slows down and he can dissect defenses methodically. His excellent command of timing routes and back-shoulder throws suggests someone built for possession-style offenses that emphasize ball control over explosive plays. While his arm strength opens up every throw on the route tree, his rushing limitations mean he won't be creating magic with his legs when plays break down - a reality that could expose him against NFL pass rushes that generate consistent pressure.

The Indiana move represents a crucial test case for his development. Cignetti's system should highlight Mendoza's ability to process information quickly and deliver accurate strikes in rhythm, but it will also reveal whether his pocket-passing approach can survive when facing elite collegiate athletes who mirror what he'll see on Sundays. His track record of taking punishment while standing tall offers encouragement, though the question remains whether adding twenty pounds of muscle will be enough to withstand 300-pound defensive ends who run 4.6 forties.

Mendoza's ceiling hinges on proving he can maintain his accuracy and decision-making when operating behind less-than-ideal protection, something every NFL quarterback must navigate. His natural feel for finding throwing lanes and delivering strikes to covered receivers gives him a foundation to build upon, but his tendency to hold the ball and absorb contact rather than escape the pocket could become problematic against faster, more athletic defenders. The upcoming season will determine whether he's a polished passer ready to compete for starting jobs early in his career, or someone who needs time to adjust his internal clock to the pro game.