Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Frame needs additional functional strength to consistently battle bigger receivers in contested catch situations without getting overpowered
• Technique can get sloppy when relying too heavily on athletic ability, particularly in hand placement and footwork fundamentals
• Man coverage against elite route runners exposes some inconsistencies in his ability to mirror complex stem and break combinations
• Tackling approach needs refinement as he sometimes goes for the big hit rather than securing the sure tackle
• Limited starting experience means he's still developing the communication skills expected from a primary cornerback

Scouting Report: Summary

The 2025 season will determine whether Mathews can translate his obvious athletic gifts into consistent, polished cornerback play at the highest level. His zone coverage instincts and range suggest a natural understanding of leverage and spacing, but the technical inconsistencies that show up in man coverage reveal a player still developing his craft. NFL defensive coordinators will appreciate his versatility and competitive nature, though they'll need patience as he builds the functional strength necessary to handle bigger receivers consistently.

Mathews enters his junior year with the athletic foundation to succeed professionally, but significant questions remain about his ceiling. The ball skills and recovery speed that create highlight plays also mask fundamental technique issues that better quarterbacks will exploit. His ability to impact games in multiple roles - outside corner, slot defender, and even safety packages - creates value for teams willing to develop him gradually. However, the tackling inconsistencies and tendency to rely on athleticism over technique suggest he's still a year or two away from being a dependable every-down defender.

The upcoming season represents a crucial proving ground for his pro aspirations. If he can refine his press technique and improve his consistency in man coverage while maintaining his zone coverage strengths, he'll position himself as an intriguing mid-round selection. Teams investing in Mathews are betting on continued development rather than a finished product, which makes his 2025 production and technical improvement essential to his draft stock. The talent is clearly present, but transforming that potential into reliable professional production remains the primary challenge ahead.