Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Thinner physique raises concerns about his play strength and ability to withstand the physical rigors of the NFL, potentially limiting his effectiveness against more robust competition.
• Despite possessing elite speed metrics, there's a noticeable discrepancy between his timed speed and game speed, suggesting a need for improved speed translation to live action.
• His plant-and-drive mechanics and stopping footwork lack efficiency, leaving room for improvement in route precision and explosiveness out of breaks.
• Tendency for focus drops, particularly when attempting to extend and secure catches outside his frame, necessitating enhanced focus and hand-eye coordination.
• While capable of making catches in traffic, occasionally falls short in contested situations due to a lack of ideal physicality - need for enhanced strength.

Scouting Report: Summary

His lean frame, coupled with his exceptional athleticism, makes him a receiver with some serious upside, especially due to his vertical speed, agility, and fluidity. McMillan's technical proficiency as a route runner, characterized by his extensive route tree, spatial instincts, and throttle control, is excellent. His ability to separate and convert at the catch point is a standout feature, augmented by impressive body control, instincts, and hand technique. However, he shows some limitations against bigger corners and has been prone to focus drops.

McMillan has played both out wide and in the slot, where he poses a speed mismatch against safeties and linebackers. His expertise in route running, utilizing quick feet and hip sink, is evident. While his high school track background doesn't always fully translate to his on-field speed, limiting his effectiveness against talented press-man corners, he thrives against zone coverage. His ability to find holes in zone and create space is very good, though he sometimes struggles in crowded field conditions. McMillan's limited play strength affects his blocking ability and his effectiveness in contested catch situations, yet his precise route-running skills make him a valuable asset, particularly in the slot against zone coverage.

Despite a knee injury affecting his 2023 season, McMillan's productivity remained high, demonstrating his resilience. His speed, route-running savvy, and versatility position him well for the transition to the NFL. Expect McMillan to be selected in the third or fourth round of the 2024 NFL draft and carve out a nice career as a slot reciever.