Top Top Kick Accuracy Player Ratings Most reliable kickers

Every Madden release in NFL history, ranked by top kick accuracy. Top 100 single-season ratings — filter by era or position group.

Era: All-time 2020s 2010s 2000s
Position: All positions QB RB WR TE OL DL LB DB ST
Showing 100 entries — 2010s , QB
# Player Team Madden KAC
1
Ryan Tannehill

QB
Ryan
Tannehill

Dolphins 2019 72
2
Ben Roethlisberger

QB
Ben
Roethlisberger

Steelers 2019 65
3
David Fales

QB
David
Fales

Jets 2020 62
4
Ryan Finley

QB
Ryan
Finley

Bengals 2020 62
5
Taylor Heinicke

QB
Taylor
Heinicke

Panthers 2019 57
6
Daniel Jones

QB
Daniel
Jones

Giants 2020 49
7
Will Grier

QB
Will
Grier

Panthers 2020 45
8
Trace McSorley

QB
Trace
McSorley

Ravens 2020 40
9
Marcus Mariota

QB
Marcus
Mariota

Titans 2020 36
10
Jake Delhomme

QB
Jake
Delhomme

Browns 2011 36
11
Jon Kitna

QB
Jon
Kitna

Cowboys 2011 36
12
Drew Brees

QB
Drew
Brees

Saints 2019 35
13
Jimmy Clausen

QB
Jimmy
Clausen

Bears 2016 35
14
Brett Favre

QB
Brett
Favre

Vikings 2011 34
15
Colt McCoy

QB
Colt
McCoy

Commanders 2020 32
16
Blake Bortles

QB
Blake
Bortles

Rams 2020 32
17
Terrelle Pryor

QB
Terrelle
Pryor

Seahawks 2015 32
18
Chris Redman

QB
Chris
Redman

Falcons 2013 32
19
Tarvaris Jackson

QB
Tarvaris
Jackson

Seahawks 2016 31
20
Easton Stick

QB
Easton
Stick

Chargers 2020 30
21
Jordan Palmer

QB
Jordan
Palmer

Bears 2015 30
22
Sage Rosenfels

QB
Sage
Rosenfels

Vikings 2011 30
23
Keith Null

QB
Keith
Null

Rams 2011 30
24
Andrew Luck

QB
Andrew
Luck

Colts 2020 28
25
Charlie Whitehurst

QB
Charlie
Whitehurst

Titans 2016 28
26
Jarrett Stidham

QB
Jarrett
Stidham

Patriots 2020 27
27
Vince Young

QB
Vince
Young

Bills 2013 27
28
Jameis Winston

QB
Jameis
Winston

Buccaneers 2020 26
29
Matt Simms

QB
Matt
Simms

Bills 2016 26
30
Johnny Manziel

QB
Johnny
Manziel

Browns 2016 26
31
Greg McElroy

QB
Greg
McElroy

Jets 2014 26
32
Mike Kafka

QB
Mike
Kafka

Eagles 2013 26
33
Jim Sorgi

QB
Jim
Sorgi

Giants 2011 26
34
Matt Ryan

QB
Matt
Ryan

Falcons 2020 25
35
Joe Flacco

QB
Joe
Flacco

Broncos 2020 25
36
Chad Henne

QB
Chad
Henne

Chiefs 2020 25
37
Matthew Stafford

QB
Matthew
Stafford

Lions 2020 25
38
Nick Foles

QB
Nick
Foles

Jaguars 2020 25
39
Case Keenum

QB
Case
Keenum

Commanders 2020 25
40
Matt Barkley

QB
Matt
Barkley

Bills 2020 25
41
Teddy Bridgewater

QB
Teddy
Bridgewater

Saints 2020 25
42
Deshaun Watson

QB
Deshaun
Watson

Texans 2020 25
43
Josh McCown

QB
Josh
McCown

Jets 2019 25
44
Matt Moore

QB
Matt
Moore

Dolphins 2018 25
45
Josh Johnson

QB
Josh
Johnson

Giants 2018 25
46
Scott Tolzien

QB
Scott
Tolzien

Colts 2018 25
47
Kellen Moore

QB
Kellen
Moore

Cowboys 2017 25
48
Sean Renfree

QB
Sean
Renfree

Falcons 2017 25
49
Matt Flynn

QB
Matt
Flynn

Patriots 2016 25
50
Rudy Carpenter

QB
Rudy
Carpenter

Cowboys 2013 25
51
Tom Brandstater

QB
Tom
Brandstater

Rams 2013 25
52
Brian Brohm

QB
Brian
Brohm

Bills 2011 25
53
Dennis Dixon

QB
Dennis
Dixon

Steelers 2011 25
54
Tony Pike

QB
Tony
Pike

Panthers 2011 25
55
Joe Webb

QB
Joe
Webb

Texans 2020 24
56
Peyton Manning

QB
Peyton
Manning

Broncos 2016 24
57
Dominique Davis

QB
Dominique
Davis

Falcons 2015 24
58
Thaddeus Lewis

QB
Thaddeus
Lewis

Browns 2013 24
59
Mitchell Trubisky

QB
Mitchell
Trubisky

Bears 2020 23
60
Donovan McNabb

QB
Donovan
McNabb

Commanders 2011 23
61
Cam Newton

QB
Cam
Newton

Panthers 2020 22
62
Blaine Gabbert

QB
Blaine
Gabbert

Buccaneers 2020 22
63
Robert Griffin III

QB
Robert
Griffin III

Ravens 2020 22
64
Dak Prescott

QB
Dak
Prescott

Cowboys 2020 22
65
Ryan Griffin

QB
Ryan
Griffin

Buccaneers 2020 22
66
Brandon Weeden

QB
Brandon
Weeden

Texans 2019 22
67
Cardale Jones

QB
Cardale
Jones

Bills 2018 22
68
Michael Vick

QB
Michael
Vick

Jets 2015 22
69
Jeff Tuel

QB
Jeff
Tuel

Bills 2015 22
70
Charlie Batch

QB
Charlie
Batch

Steelers 2013 22
71
Caleb Hanie

QB
Caleb
Hanie

Broncos 2013 22
72
A.J. Feeley

QB
A.J.
Feeley

Rams 2011 22
73
Mike Glennon

QB
Mike
Glennon

Raiders 2020 21
74
Derek Carr

QB
Derek
Carr

Raiders 2020 21
75
Brett Hundley

QB
Brett
Hundley

Cardinals 2020 21
76
Nate Sudfeld

QB
Nate
Sudfeld

Eagles 2020 21
77
Drew Stanton

QB
Drew
Stanton

Browns 2019 21
78
Jason Campbell

QB
Jason
Campbell

Bengals 2015 21
79
David Carr

QB
David
Carr

Giants 2014 21
80
John Beck

QB
John
Beck

Texans 2013 21
81
Cody Kessler

QB
Cody
Kessler

Eagles 2020 20
82
Jared Goff

QB
Jared
Goff

Rams 2020 20
83
Jacoby Brissett

QB
Jacoby
Brissett

Colts 2020 20
84
Jeff Driskel

QB
Jeff
Driskel

Bengals 2020 20
85
Kevin Hogan

QB
Kevin
Hogan

Broncos 2020 20
86
Brandon Allen

QB
Brandon
Allen

Rams 2020 20
87
P.J. Walker

QB
P.J.
Walker

Colts 2020 20
88
Bryce Petty

QB
Bryce
Petty

Dolphins 2019 20
89
Jake Rudock

QB
Jake
Rudock

Lions 2019 20
90
Joe Callahan

QB
Joe
Callahan

Eagles 2019 20
91
Paxton Lynch

QB
Paxton
Lynch

Broncos 2019 20
92
Chad Kelly

QB
Chad
Kelly

Broncos 2019 20
93
Taysom Hill

QB
Taysom
Hill

Saints 2019 20
94
Trevone Boykin

QB
Trevone
Boykin

Seahawks 2018 20
95
Connor Cook

QB
Connor
Cook

Raiders 2018 20
96
Jay Cutler

QB
Jay
Cutler

Bears 2017 20
97
Colin Kaepernick

QB
Colin
Kaepernick

49ers 2017 20
98
Josh Freeman

QB
Josh
Freeman

Dolphins 2016 20
99
Christian Ponder

QB
Christian
Ponder

Raiders 2016 20
100
Connor Shaw

QB
Connor
Shaw

Browns 2016 20

Other Special leaderboards